They could only mark the beginning of responsibility.
That afternoon, I called my company’s legal director, Zhao Ming.
He had worked for me for eleven years and was one of the few people whose judgment I respected.
“I need an independent review of every financial transaction Chen Haoyu authorized during the last eight years.”
Zhao Ming sounded surprised.
“Mr. Lu, is something wrong?”
“Possibly something very serious.”
“Should I inform Vice President Chen?”
“No.”
There was a pause.
“Understood.”
“And Zhao Ming?”
“Yes?”
“Preserve everything. Contracts, financial records, emails, access logs. Nothing is to be deleted.”
I ended the call.
My next call was to an independent forensic accountant recommended by an outside law firm.
By evening, arrangements had begun for a confidential audit.
But I knew Haoyu would not remain unaware for long.
He had helped build the company.
He knew our systems, our employees, and my habits better than almost anyone.
Most importantly, he knew that I had trusted him without question.
That night, I stayed in Hangzhou.
I could not bring myself to return to Shanghai.
Madam Su reluctantly allowed me to sit in the living room of the small apartment where Wanning and Yichen had lived.
The furniture was simple.
There was a worn sofa, a wooden dining table, and shelves crowded with children’s books.
On the refrigerator hung drawings of houses, animals, and smiling people holding hands.
One drawing caught my attention.
It showed a woman and a little boy standing outside a house.
A third figure had been drawn in pencil, then erased.
I touched the paper gently.
“Yichen drew that when he was five,” Madam Su said.
I turned.
“He asked Wanning why everyone else at school had a father.”
My eyes filled again.
“What did she tell him?”
“She said families could look different, but that love didn’t depend on how many people lived in a house.”
Madam Su sat heavily in a chair.
“Later, when he became older, he began asking more questions.”
“About me?”
She nodded.
“Wanning didn’t want him to hate you. But she also couldn’t tell him the whole truth. She was afraid he might try to find you.”
I looked at the little erased figure.
“Did he ever see my photograph?”
“Once.”
My heart pounded.
“He found an old wedding picture. Wanning told him the man beside her had been someone very important.”
“Did he ask who?”
“Yes.”
“What did she say?”
Madam Su looked away.
“She said he was someone she hoped would one day understand what he had lost.”
I sat down.
For a long time, neither of us spoke.
Then Madam Su brought me a small cardboard box.
“These are some things Wanning kept.”
Inside were photographs, birthday cards, and dozens of unsent letters.
I picked up the first envelope.
To Jingshen, on Yichen’s first birthday.
My hands began shaking.
I opened it.
Today our son took three steps before falling into my arms. He laughed so loudly that I laughed too.
He has your eyes.
Sometimes I wish you could see him.
Sometimes I am grateful you cannot hurt him the way you hurt me.
I opened another.
To Jingshen, on Yichen’s third birthday.
He asked whether his father liked airplanes. I told him yes, because I remembered the model airplane you kept on your office desk.
He wants to become a pilot.
I remembered the toy airplane he had been holding beside the coffin.
Another letter was dated two years later.
Yichen has started school. He is clever, stubborn, and sometimes impossibly serious.
When he frowns, he looks so much like you that I have to turn away.
I hope he inherits your determination but not your pride.
I read until midnight.
Each letter contained a life I had never known.
A first fever.
A first lost tooth.
A school performance.
A broken toy.
A question about why other fathers came to pick up their children.
By the time I reached the last envelope, my tears had soaked the paper.
It was dated three weeks before Wanning died.
Jingshen, the doctors say my treatment is no longer working.
I am frightened.
Not because I am afraid of dying, but because Yichen still reaches for my hand when he sleeps.
He is only seven.
He deserves to grow up without feeling abandoned.
I don’t know whether you will ever come.
But if you do, please don’t try to buy his love.
Don’t give him expensive toys and expect him to call you Father.
Sit with him. Listen to him. Keep your promises.
And please, if you can, become the man I once believed you were.
I pressed the letter to my chest.
“I will,” I whispered.
But Wanning could no longer hear me.
The following morning, Zhao Ming called.
His voice was tense.
“Mr. Lu, we found something unusual.”
I stepped onto the balcony.
“What?”
“Several subcontractors associated with our Hangzhou development projects received payments totaling more than eighty million yuan.”
My stomach tightened.
“Were the projects completed?”
“Some were. Others appear to involve duplicate invoices or services we can’t verify.”
“Who approved them?”
“Vice President Chen.”
I closed my eyes.
“Anything else?”
“Some approvals carry your digital authorization.”
“I never approved those transactions.”
“I believe you. But someone used credentials assigned to your office.”
I looked through the window toward Yichen, who was eating breakfast with his grandmother.
“Can you identify who accessed them?”
“We’re examining the logs. There are irregularities.”
“Keep going.”
Zhao Ming hesitated.
“Mr. Lu, there’s another problem.”
“What?”
“Vice President Chen requested an emergency transfer of company funds this morning.”
My blood ran cold.
“How much?”
“Twenty million yuan.”
“Stop it.”
“The finance department has already placed a temporary hold pending verification.”
“Good. Notify our external counsel and preserve the request.”
“Mr. Lu, Chen is asking where you are.”
“Tell him I’ll speak with him soon.”
I ended the call.
Before I could go inside, my phone buzzed.
An unknown number had sent a message.
You should have stayed away from Hangzhou.
Below the message was a photograph.
It showed Yichen leaving his school building several weeks earlier.
My hands turned cold.
Another message followed.
Some truths are better buried with the dead.
I immediately called Zhao Ming and sent him screenshots.
He advised me to contact the police.
For once, I didn’t hesitate.
Within an hour, I had reported the threats to the local authorities and arranged lawful security measures for Madam Su and Yichen.
I also asked the lawyers to ensure the family’s privacy was protected.
When I returned to the apartment, Yichen looked up from his breakfast.
“Why is everyone whispering?”
I forced myself to remain calm.
“Some adults are dealing with a problem.”
“Is someone going to take me away?”
His question nearly broke me.
I knelt beside the table.
“No one is going to take you anywhere today.”
He searched my face.
“Promise?”
I hesitated.
Wanning had asked me to keep my promises.
I would not make one I could not control.
“I promise I will do everything I can to keep you safe. And I’ll tell you the truth when something important happens.”
He stared at me for a long moment.
Then he nodded.
It was not forgiveness.
But it was the first time he had listened without turning away.
The funeral ceremony continued that afternoon.
I stood near the back as relatives and friends paid their respects.
Wanning’s former coworkers spoke about her kindness.
A neighbor remembered how she had helped elderly residents carry groceries.
One mother described how Wanning had organized a fundraiser for a sick child despite struggling with medical bills of her own.
Every story revealed another part of the woman I had failed to know.
When the ceremony ended, Yichen approached the coffin holding a drawing.
It showed him and Wanning standing beneath a bright yellow sun.
He placed it beside her hands.
“Mom,” he whispered, “I finished the picture.”
His small shoulders shook.
“I didn’t draw Daddy because I didn’t know what he looked like.”
I stood several feet away, unable to move.
Yichen continued.
“But he came today.”
He looked toward me.
“I don’t know if I like him.”
My throat closed.
Then he turned back toward the coffin.
“Grandma says I don’t have to decide yet.”
He placed his palm against the polished wood.
“Mom, I wish you could tell me what to do.”
Madam Su began crying.
I lowered my head.
Nothing in my life had ever made me feel so powerless.
After the burial, I returned to Shanghai to confront the man responsible for destroying my family.
But I didn’t go alone.
Zhao Ming and two independent legal advisers accompanied me.
We met in a conference room away from the company headquarters.
The audit team had found enough irregularities to justify immediate action.
Several shell companies had received payments connected to projects overseen by Haoyu.
Bank records and corporate filings suggested links to people close to him.
There were also inconsistencies in project inspection documents.
But the most disturbing discovery was a series of messages preserved in an old company email archive.
One message, sent shortly before my divorce, contained the words:
The problem with Su Wanning must be resolved before she speaks to Lu.
Another read:
The hotel photograph is ready. Make certain Bai Xiulan receives it first.
The sender’s account was associated with a former assistant who had worked directly for Haoyu.
I stared at the screen.
For seven years, that photograph had been the foundation of my hatred.
Now I was looking at evidence that it had been deliberately arranged.
The photographer had captured Wanning leaving a hotel after meeting a doctor.
The image was real.
The story attached to it was false.
And I had never bothered to ask the difference.
At three that afternoon, Haoyu entered the conference room.
He smiled when he saw me.
“Jingshen! I’ve been trying to reach you. How was the funeral?”
I said nothing.
His smile faded when he noticed the lawyers.
“What’s going on?”
I slid a copy of the preserved email across the table.
“Recognize this?”
He glanced at it.
His expression barely changed.
“An old email? What’s your point?”
“Someone in your office arranged the photograph of Wanning.”
He leaned back.
“That’s ridiculous.”
“The original photographer has been identified.”
A flicker of concern crossed his face.
I continued.
“He was paid through a company connected to one of your associates.”
Haoyu looked toward the door.
“You’ve been busy.”
“Why did you do it?”
He smiled faintly.
“You’re making accusations based on things you don’t understand.”
I placed the financial summaries in front of him.
“Eighty million yuan in questionable payments. False invoices. Documents bearing my authorization when I wasn’t even in China.”
His eyes hardened.
“Be careful, Jingshen.”
“That’s what you told me at the funeral.”
“Because you’re acting emotionally.”
I leaned forward.
“Did Wanning discover your fraud?”
He remained silent.
“Did you destroy my marriage to stop her from telling me?”
Haoyu laughed without humor.
“You always were easier to manipulate than you liked to believe.”
The room went still.
I stared at him.
He looked at the lawyers, then back at me.
“You think I’m going to confess because you’re angry?”
“No,” I said. “I think you’ll have to answer questions based on the evidence.”
His expression changed.
“You should remember something. Those documents carry your name.”
“I know.”
“Then perhaps you should be more concerned about your own future.”
For years, that threat would have frightened me into protecting the company at any cost.
But something had changed.
“I’d rather lose the company than continue living inside your lies.”
For the first time, Haoyu seemed genuinely surprised.
He stood.
“You have no idea what you’re doing.”
I remained seated.
“Maybe not. But I’m finally doing something I should have done seven years ago.”
He left without another word.
Later that evening, our legal team formally referred the suspected financial misconduct and document forgery to the appropriate authorities.
Haoyu was suspended from his management responsibilities pending investigation.
But the story was far from over.
Two days later, the police contacted me.
The former assistant connected to the hotel photograph had agreed to provide information.
His name was Liu Peng.
He had worked for Haoyu during the years when my marriage collapsed.
According to his statement, Haoyu had instructed him to monitor Wanning after she questioned company payments.
When she visited the hotel to meet Dr. Zhou, Liu Peng arranged for a photographer to capture images from an angle that made the meeting appear suspicious.
He then delivered those photographs to my mother.
The plan depended on two things.
My mother’s distrust of Wanning.
And my jealousy.
Haoyu had correctly predicted both.
Liu Peng also described meetings where Haoyu discussed preventing Wanning from contacting me.
But one detail haunted me more than the others.
After the divorce, Wanning had come to my office carrying an ultrasound photograph.
She waited outside for nearly four hours.
When Liu Peng informed Haoyu, he was told to send her away.
“She kept saying she only needed five minutes with Mr. Lu,” Liu Peng recalled in his statement.
“Did she leave a message?” I asked through the investigator.
“Yes.”
“What was it?”
Liu Peng hesitated.
“She said, ‘Please tell him our baby is healthy. I don’t want anything from him. I just want him to know.’”
I closed my eyes.
Five minutes.
That was all she had asked for.
I could have given her five minutes.
Instead, I had spent seven years giving my time to the man who betrayed us.
The investigation continued.
The police examined financial records, witness accounts, messages, and other evidence.
As the case developed, Haoyu’s carefully constructed reputation began collapsing.
It emerged that several of his associates had benefited from diverted payments.
The investigators also found evidence suggesting that people connected to Haoyu had been responsible for threatening Wanning.
But her illness remained a separate and painful question.
Had he caused her death?
Had he interfered with her treatment?
I wanted answers.
I wanted someone to blame for every moment of suffering she had endured.
Yet I knew anger was not evidence.
Through legal channels and with Madam Su’s permission, we obtained Wanning’s medical history for review by independent specialists.
The records confirmed that she had received treatment for lymphoma over two years.
Her doctors had tried several approaches, and there had been periods of improvement followed by relapse.
The specialists found no reliable medical evidence that Haoyu had caused the disease.
They also could not conclude that the threats had directly caused her death.
What the records did reveal was heartbreaking enough.
Wanning had missed or postponed some appointments while dealing with financial difficulty, childcare responsibilities, and repeated disruptions to her life.
At times, she had concealed the severity of her symptoms from her family.
She had been frightened.
Exhausted.
And increasingly alone.
I sat with those records for hours.
I wanted a simple answer.
An evil man had killed my wife.
That would have allowed me to direct all my pain toward Haoyu.
But the truth was more complicated.
Haoyu had destroyed our marriage and continued threatening her.
My mother had helped conceal her pregnancy.
And I had abandoned her when she needed me most.
None of us could escape responsibility for our own choices.
One evening, I returned to Hangzhou and found Madam Su sitting beside the window.
She was holding one of Wanning’s scarves.
“Did you learn anything?” she asked.
I sat opposite her.
“The investigation is continuing. There is evidence of threats and financial crimes. But the doctors can’t say that anyone caused her illness.”
Madam Su nodded slowly.
“I never wanted revenge for her sickness,” she whispered. “I wanted her to have peace while she was alive.”
I lowered my head.
“I know.”
“She worked until she couldn’t stand for long periods. She worried about hospital bills. She worried about Yichen’s school.”
Tears rolled down her cheeks.
“Sometimes she told me she wished she could sleep for a week without anyone needing her.”
I covered my eyes.
Madam Su continued.
“But whenever Yichen called her, she smiled. Even when she was hurting.”
We sat silently.
Then she said something I would never forget.
“Jingshen, you cannot bring my daughter back. But there is still a child in this house who needs adults who won’t fail him.”
I nodded.
“I understand.”
“No,” she said gently. “You are only beginning to understand.”
She was right.
Over the following weeks, I began traveling to Hangzhou regularly.
At first, Yichen refused to speak to me.
He would leave the room whenever I arrived.
If I brought food, he said he wasn’t hungry.
If I asked about school, he said it was none of my business.
I accepted his anger.
I had earned it.
One Saturday afternoon, I noticed him struggling with a broken toy airplane at the dining table.
A wheel had come loose.
“Would you like some help?” I asked.
“No.”
I nodded and sat on the opposite side of the room.
Ten minutes passed.
Then twenty.
Finally, he sighed.
“Do you know how to fix these?”
I looked up.
“A little.”
He slid the airplane toward me.
“Don’t break it more.”
“I’ll be careful.”
I examined the wheel and found that a small plastic connector had snapped.
“I think we can repair this with a replacement piece.”
He watched suspiciously.
“Mom bought it for my sixth birthday.”
I looked at the airplane.
“Then it’s important.”
He nodded.
“Very.”
I didn’t try to replace it with a more expensive toy.
Instead, I spent the afternoon finding a compatible part and helping him fit it into place.
When the wheel finally turned, Yichen smiled.
It was a brief smile.
But it was the first one he had given me.
“Thank you,” he whispered.
“You’re welcome.”
He picked up the airplane and ran toward his grandmother.
“Grandma! It works again!”
Madam Su looked at me across the room.
For the first time, her expression contained something other than anger.
Perhaps it was not forgiveness.
Perhaps it was simply recognition that I was trying.
That was enough.
As the months passed, I learned things about my son that no business report could ever contain.
He hated carrots but loved steamed pumpkin.
He preferred drawing airplanes to playing video games.
He was frightened of thunderstorms, though he pretended otherwise.
He liked mathematics and struggled with writing essays.
When he was nervous, he rubbed his thumb against his index finger.
I did the same thing.
The resemblance between us went beyond our faces.
Sometimes, watching him, I felt as though I was discovering a forgotten part of myself.
But Yichen was not merely a smaller version of me.
He was his own person.
And he carried Wanning within him too.
He was gentle with stray animals.
He remembered birthdays.
He noticed when his grandmother looked tired and quietly brought her a glass of water.
Those things came from her.
Every time I saw them, I loved him more.
One afternoon, while we were walking beside West Lake, Yichen suddenly asked a question.
“Were you really married to Mom?”
I stopped.
“Yes.”
“Did you love her?”
I looked across the water.
“Very much.”
“Then why did you leave?”
I took a slow breath.
“Because I believed something terrible about her without listening to her explanation.”
He frowned.
“Was it true?”
“No.”
“Did you know it wasn’t true?”
“Not then. But I should have listened. I should have checked.”
Yichen kicked a small pebble along the path.